Opening with Frank spontaneously asking Claire to marry him outside the register’s office and skipping in to get hitched while his parents wait at a nearby restaurant, still rubs the reader me a bit sad.
I miss the shock of Claire seeing the then new kirk she was to wed Jamie in as the same old kirk she and Frank married in. That moment of panic was a touchstone for me. A reaction, not a complaint.
Yes, yes I know Diana writes big and detailed books. The adaptation writer and team must pick and choose from what is absolutely necessary for the characters and overall story to move forward properly from a visual storytelling perspective. Sometimes what is purposeful in the written form is too big and unwieldy for the visual form. I get it, yet I will still have “oh man I wanted to SEE xxxxx” moments.
I also understand the need to keep Frank solidly in the viewer’s mind. Sympathy and positive thoughts toward him will help soften the viewer to Claire’s future choices and behaviors. Otherwise it is far too easy getting lost in why would Claire ever leave question. 18th century Scotland and the growing relationship between Claire and Jamie is so present and beautiful.
The contrast to Frank’s practicality in love to Jamie’s desires for particular wedding conditions and faith is quite vast. Frank obviously loves Claire and she him. A practical solid love. Jamie has a depth about how he views family, clan, promises, faith, and love. He is very serious and passionate about it. He obviously loves Claire and she is conflicted in her fondness and attraction to him. You know the whole bigamist and adulteress thing.
I am enjoying this particular path showing the two almost side by side. The relationships between each duo.
I did very much like showing the pre-wedding kiss between Frank and Claire just before flashing to the wedding kiss of Claire and Jamie. The giddy joy of one to the “what have I done this just got real” of the other. I almost had a flash of the Carrie Underwood song “Last Name”.
Flashing to the wedding night chamber, I adore the openness and ease in which Jamie and Claire converse as the evening continues. Clearly and plainly there is a trust between them. A slow burn with a quick intimacy built.
I wonder if Frank and Claire really talked about everything or with such ease before or after their wedding day. Claire seemed a bit young and subordinate to Frank in interaction almost like he was always trying to be teacher, a father figure type. With Jamie even early on they teach each other, have a comfort level that defied the relational boundaries. This simply and beautiful flowed in the post wedding scenes.
That’s it for now.
2 thoughts on “Afterthoughts Ep107 The Weddings”
I agree with all you said. I, too, was looking forward to Claire’s shock when she realized she was going to marry Jamie in the same church where she had married Frank, but Ron Moore did a good job of explaining why logistics didn’t permit it. I missed it, but there are many other scenes I’d have missed a great deal more had they been eliminated.
I think many of the changes in this episode were geared to making better TV, but still keeping book readers placated. The bit about the procurement of the wedding dress definitely made for better TV.
I’m still puzzled about the ring and would bet the farm that later on — back at Leoch perhaps — Jamie will have the silver ring with the thistles and inscription made for Claire. It’s just too important to leave out, IMO. Thousands of replicas of the ring were sold after Outlander was published. I have one of them. http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y109/magicdancer/Outlander/aa_clairesring_zps429f4103.jpg~original The Ladies of Lallybroch fan club presented Diana with the first one so I think Diana would have fought to keep the ring in the film. Jamie using his key to Lallybroch was a nice touch, but I hope it doesn’t end with that. I’m told the Starz store is selling replicas of the ring made from the key. That makes me a bit concerned.
Did you see the YouTube BTS video about filming The Wedding episode? It’s adorable the way Sam and Cait are so affectionate in real life and their talk about filming nudity and Cait’s struggle with the wedding dress are priceless.
Absolutely agree. I get it the changes. Yes the ring is too important to not have later.
I adored the behind scenes posted it on FB and Twitter